Monday, February 29, 2016

Social Justice and Struggle

The school year in Peru starts next Monday, so life is finally settling into more of a pattern here in the Mountain House. Last Saturday, we sat down as a JV (Jesuit Volunteer) community to check in about each of our understandings of the four pillars of JVC: community, spirituality, simple living, and social justice. We reflected on both our current understanding of each value as well as our hopes for how those values might be lived out in our community over the next year.

When the conversation turned to social justice, I thought at first that I wouldn’t have much to say. I’m still only just beginning to understand the social reality of the community in Andahuaylillas. I can’t yet name many of the issues of social justice present here, and the ones I am aware of I’ve learned second-hand. I have so much still to learn, and so, as one of my communitymates expressed, most of what I think of when I reflect on social justice as a value is my role as a student here in Peru. I’m sure I will have many teachers in the next two years that will teach me in many different ways about what it’s like to live in Peru.

But in reflecting more on these first three months living in Andahuaylillas, I’ve realized that I have learned a lot about what social justice means in this context, though that understanding has come in unexpected ways.

In many ways, the past three months has been a time of a lot of frustration. The process of becoming a resident of Peru has involved multiple 24-hour bus trips, long lines, much confusion, and a seemingly endless and jumbled array of bureaucratic hoops to jump through. We never seem to be in the right place with the right documents, and I swear one of the immigration officials savors the task of telling us that sorry, we need to come back again with yet another change in our paperwork. Aside from that, I’ve been sick a couple of times and haven’t necessarily received the same quality of care that I would have access to in the US. I’ve struggled with feelings of isolation that come from living in a small rural town where the ways I look and speak mean that it’s easy for people to identify me as an outsider.

What I’ve learned about social justice so far can be directly tied to all of the ways that I’ve struggled so far in this experience. There have been more than a few instances during my time here that have made me feel something along the lines of, “oh shit, what have I gotten myself into?” But it’s those same times that have provided the most occasions for reflection and ultimately (I hope) have fostered an increase in my capacity for empathy and invited me into greater solidarity with this community. I understand just a tiny bit better what it might be like to go through the immigration process in the US, the injustice of unequal access to quality healthcare, and the experience of being a visible minority within a particular community.

Perhaps more significantly, those same experiences of personal struggle and frustration have shed light on the enormous amount of privilege I bring with me to my time as a JV. This is a reality that I’ve chosen to participate in for a finite amount of time, and I hope to experience it as deeply and whole-heartedly as I can, but I also have to recognize the immense privilege present in that choice alone. The immigration process here has been kind of like a long, drawn-out trip to the DMV—but ultimately I’m confident that once all of the paperwork is sorted out I’ll be approved to stay, which is more than a great many migrants can say. I also know that I have a safe place to return to at the end of my time in Peru, unlike many refugees going through the same processes. The annoyance of intestinal infections and subsequent visits to the clinic is bothersome, but as a JV I have excellent health insurance that allows me to access medical care whenever I need it, as well as any medication I might need. And although the standard of care may be different from what I’m used to back at home, it’s also far beyond what many of the people in my current community and the global community have access to. It’s made me especially aware of what a privilege it is to have access to clean, safe drinking water both here in Peru and in the US, and to be able to take steps to improve the quality of that water when necessary. The isolation and loneliness I’ve sometimes felt here are real and valid feelings, but I will never know what it’s like to face systemic injustices based on the color of my skin. If anything, being white and from the US in this community means that I’m often given special treatment, like being told to skip lines at the clinic or being entrusted with more responsibility at the parish.

The pillar of social justice in my time as a JV so far has been an exercise in keeping things in perspective. When issues of justice affect my life here, while I want to honor the feelings and struggles that surface for me, I’m also trying to continuously remind myself of the broader picture. What does that issue of justice look like on a greater scale, and who might it be impacting more than it’s impacting me? How can I turn that frustration into an occasion to enter more deeply into an understanding of both my own privilege and the reality of the community I’ve entered into?


When I really reflect on my struggles in that way, I’m grateful for the opportunity to better understand both my own reality and that of the people whose community I am slowly becoming a part of. An expanding capacity for empathy and increased understanding of self and the world—God is totally at work here, through all of the growing pains. And isn’t that why I came here in the first place?